1984 – Carol Compton '84 (2nd Team, field hockey, women's lacrosse)
1998 – Jim Mangan '98 (3rd Team, men's cross country)
1998 – Dave Rakoff '98 (3rd Team, men's track & field)
1999 – Sam Floyd '99 (2nd Team, men's cross country)
1999 – Ian Pitha-Rowe '99 (2nd Team, men's lacrosse)
2000 – Asa Hopkins '01 (1st Team, men's fencing)
2001 – Asa Hopkins '01 (1st Team, men's fencing)
2001 – Shelli Frey '01 (3rd Team, women's track & field)
2002 – Katrina Julian ’04 (3rd Team, women’s soccer)
2002 – Peter Rook '02 (2nd Team, men's cross country, men's track & field)
2004 – Scott Sargrad '04 (2nd Team, men's cross country, men's track & field)
2004 – Don Grunewald '04 (3rd Team, men's fencing)
2004 – Jonas Clark ’04 (2nd Team, baseball)
2005 – Eddie Papalia '05 (3rd Team, men's cross country, men's track & field)
2006 – Grant Scott '06 (1st Team, men's cross country, men's track & field)
2007 – Aislinn Sowash '07 (3rd Team, women's cross country, women's track & field)
2015 – Tommy Bergjans ’15 (3rd Team, baseball)
2015 – Sam Yarosh ’16 (1st Team, men’s soccer)
2018 – Dylan Gearinger '19 (2nd Team, men's cross country, men's track & field), Henry Woods '18 (3rd Team, men's cross country, men's track & field)
2019 – Greg Morgan '19 (3rd Team, men's cross country, men's track & field)