Indoor Track & Field All-Americans
| Year | Name | Event |
| 1986 | Liam O'Neill | 1,500m |
| 1989 | Seamus McElligott | 5,000m |
| 1990 | Seamus McElligott * | 5,000m |
| 1991 | Matt Leighninger | 800m |
| 1991 | Matt Leighninger * | 1,500m |
| 1991 | Seamus McElligott | 1,500m |
| 1991 | Seamus McElligott | 5,000m |
| 1992 | Brian Peabody | 800m |
| 1992 | Matt Leighninger | 1,500m |
| 1993 | Aaron Curry | 1,500m |
| 1994 | Aaron Curry * | 1,500m |
| 1994 | Karl Paranya * | 800m |
| 1995 | Karl Paranya * | 800m |
| 1995 | Karl Paranya * | 1,500m |
| 1996 | Karl Paranya | 800m |
| 1996 | Karl Paranya * | 1,500m |
| 1997 | Karl Paranya * | 1,500m |
| 1997 | Ntobeko Ntusi | 800m |
| 1999 | Jason Bernstein | 1,500m |
| 2000 | Chris Johnstone, Matt Duques, Chris Ward, J.B. Haglund | DMR |
| 2001 | J.B. Haglund | 1,500m |
| 2001 | Chris Johnstone, Chris Ward, Peter Rook, J.B. Haglund | DMR |
| 2002 | J.B. Haglund | 5,000m |
| 2002 | Peter Rook | 1,500m |
| 2002 | Greg Bielecki, Chris Ward, Chris Johnstone, J.B. Haglund * | DMR |
| 2003 | Greg Bielecki | 800m |
| 2005 | Bobby Cannon, Garvey Camilien, Eddie Papalia, Ian Ramsey-North | DMR |
| 2007 | Donald Letts | 5,000m |
| 2008 | Joe Awantang | Shot Put |
| 2009 | Chaz Thomas | Long Jump |
| 2010 | Ivo Milic-Strkalj | Mile |
| 2011 | Eric Arnold, Andrew Golato, Ivo Milic-Strkalj, Tim Schoch | DMR |
| 2012 | Tim Schoch | 800m |
| 2012 | Jordan Schilit | 5,000m |
| 2013 | Christopher Stadler * | 5,000m |
| 2013 | Ivo Milic-Strkalj, Gebby Keny, Michael Riccio, Jordan Schilit | DMR |
| 2014 | Christopher Stadler | 3,000m |
| 2014 | Charlie Marquardt, Jonathan Yellets, Gebby Keny, Christopher Stadler | DMR |
| 2015 | Charlie Marquardt | 3,000m |
| 2016 | Charlie Marquardt | Mile |
| 2018 | Dylan Gearinger * | 3,000m |
| 2018 | Greg Morgan | Mile |
| 2019 | Greg Morgan * | 3,000m |
| 2020 | Matt Katz | Mile |
| 2020 | Jamie Moreland | Mile |