Emily Reinstadtler joined the Haverford College softball team as an assistant coach prior to the 2023 season. Reinstadtler rejoins the Fords after playing for the team during the 2019-2022 seasons, where she was named team captain during her senior season.

During her college career, Reinstadtler also worked as a student advancement officer manager and as a customs person. Emily was also awarded the Centennial Conference Academic Honor Roll twice during her time at Haverford. Reinstadtler had an excellent high school career where she was lettered in softball, was a three time all conference performer and played for the Carolina Legends club team.